Family Disputes and Mediation: A Guide to Resolving Family Conflicts
Family disputes can be upsetting and stressful, ranging from minor disagreements to major conflicts. Disputes between family members can take many forms, including spousal conflict, child custody matters and inheritance issues.
If left unresolved, these disputes can have long-term consequences for all involved.
Understanding family disputes
Often emotionally challenging and complex, family disputes cannot always be resolved without external help.
In this case, it is important to enlist the help of a specialist solicitor who has expertise in this area of law; they can answer any questions you have and guide you through your options, such as mediation, making the process as smooth and stress-free as possible.
Types of family dispute
-
Divorce and separation disputes
- There are three types of separation: trial, permanent, and legal, as well as divorce. In the event of a separation, disagreements can arise relating to infidelity or how matrimonial assets are divided up, for example.
- Mediation can be sought for discussion and mutual resolution, and separation solicitors can provide much-needed direction, as well as legally formalise any agreement reached.
-
Custody and parenting conflicts
- Family disputes are often emotionally charged, particularly when there are children involved.
- Disputes can arise relating to child custody, guardianship, visitation and safeguarding. Mediators can help you reach a mutually agreed solution, and family law experts can help minimise any stress or worry relating to these matters and advise you on your options.
-
Inheritance and estate disputes
- Losing a loved one is difficult enough without having to deal with disputes over the deceased’s will or estate.
- If you believe you’ve not been made provision for in the will or that the provision that has been made is unfair or inadequate, you can seek legal advice or attend mediation, whether you’re making a claim or defending a claim as the executor.
-
Sibling rivalries
- Common sibling rivalries stem from disputes over a parental will or how a loved one should be cared for.
- Such matters require sensitivity and tact, and it’s in everyone’s interests for the dispute to be resolved quickly and amicably, with the help of a legal professional or mediator if necessary.
-
Financial disputes
- Speaking about money can be difficult at the best of times, and financial disputes between family members are often complex and difficult to navigate. Establishing the family’s financial resources is the first step before deciding who gets what.
- Financial disputes typically relate to child support, spousal maintenance and divorce or dissolution of a civil partnership.
What is mediation?
Civil mediation is a flexible and confidential service used to settle disputes between two or more people, businesses or organisations.
An independent and impartial third party (a mediator) is appointed to sit down with all parties and help talk through the issues, negotiate and reach a mutually agreeable solution.
Mediation can take place instead of prior to or alongside legal proceedings and can be used for a multitude of issues, ranging from professional negligence and breach of contract to bankruptcy and guardianship disputes.
What are the benefits of mediation?
There are many benefits – financial, practical and emotional – to mediation.
- Mediation allows you to stay in control, unlike in court proceedings, where a judge makes all the decisions. You can decide on how you want to proceed and are not obliged to accept anything you don’t want to. You can also mutually review and change any plans as circumstances change.
- Mediation is typically less expensive and much quicker than going to court so is a far more efficient way of resolving a conflict and allows everyone to move on from the issue sooner.
- Mediation provides a safe and supportive environment. Having a third person involved means that verbal disagreements don’t escalate, no one gets threatened or intimidated, and everyone has their say. The mediator will talk to all parties privately as well as together.
- Mediation is completely confidential, unlike litigation, which is a highly public process. With mediation, only those involved are privy to what is discussed within the sessions.
- Mediation can help preserve relationships. The pressure of going to court can cause lasting damage to relationships between those involved. Mediation is a somewhat gentler way of managing a dispute, allowing for effective communication and mutual agreement.
The mediation process
Initial consultation
The mediator will explain how mediation works, what to expect and any payment arrangements. They will determine if your case is suitable for mediation and direct you to any other support services, such as online resources.
The initial session typically takes approximately 45 minutes and is held with each party separately. Joint meetings may then be arranged.
Information gathering
The purpose of information gathering is to establish the issues and how everyone is feeling. Questions will be asked of all parties to establish common issues and problem areas.
Issue identification
Using joint problem-solving approaches, the mediator will identify the issues to be discussed, label them and relay them to all parties, offering options for reaching a resolution.
Negotiation
By this stage, everyone should have a clear idea of their and other parties’ needs and interests.
The mediator may encourage the parties to shift their mindset but will never offer a solution, simply float ideas. They will not offer advice but rather encourage the parties to compromise on their demands and take on the other’s perspective.
Agreement
The ultimate goal of mediation is mutual agreement. If this can’t be reached, legal assistance may be sought, and litigation may ensue.
If an agreement is achieved, this will be documented. Family law solicitors may still be involved in formalising any agreement.
What will happen at mediation?
Mediation differs depending on the type of mediation and the nature of the dispute, but typically, the mediator will speak with all parties individually first and, if agreed, bring everyone together to discuss the issues.
Mediators are experts in communication and managing strong emotions, so they can effectively cultivate an environment where everyone can be heard and a mutually agreeable decision can be reached.
What is the difference between mediation and litigation
Mediation does not necessitate a legal professional to be involved; however, the mediator can be a legal practitioner. Litigation involves legal actions, which are brought before the court for a judge to determine an outcome. Mediation involves sitting down in a room with only the mediator and other interested parties.
Mediation is often concluded in a day, whereas litigation can take months to finalise. Court proceedings can involve numerous actors and public processes, but mediation is entirely confidential.
Seeking professional help
Specialist family solicitors can help you at whatever stage you’re at in your family dispute journey. Whether you decide to opt for mediation or to initiate legal proceedings to settle your dispute, family law solicitors can provide expert advice on the options available to you, direct you to relevant services and offer practical legal assistance if you decide to go through the courts.
Be sure to enlist a legal professional to give you peace of mind and the best possible chance of success.